Subway Plot
Kay leaned her head on Halo’s shoulder, snuggling closer. Still aglow from our catch-as-catch-can dinner and all-you-can-eat threesome, we had set off into a chilled autumn evening full of anticipation. Now on the subway to the party, I filled them in on the evening’s guest list. Their ears perked up when I mentioned a name new to them both.
“I’ve known Michael for a while,” I explained. “Very nice fellow, cute, geeky, new to exploring sex. So I invited him to try out our party. It’s a good night for it, as I was a little concerned that we might have too many girls.” Halo sat upright and moved her hips slightly. She shifted the bag in her lap and gave a mischievous glance to Kay. I leaned closer. “Could you two at least pretend you aren’t fingering each other?” I whispered. “We’re in public.”
“I’m not fingering her,” Halo protested.
Kay grinned. “I am fingering her.”
“She is,” Halo agreed. “She is fingering me.”
“Let’s just keep it quiet,” I scolded, raising a finger to my lips. I sat back. “Anyway, listen: Michael is a straight boy. When I asked him about his hopes for broadening his sexual horizons, he said that one of his biggest fantasies was to get with two women at the same time.” I smirked. “Typical straight boy, right? I mean, show a little ambition. I told him that was cool and sure, that could happen at one of our parties. But, I said, you’re cute and girls like beer. You can easily do that on your own.”
Halo turned to Kay’s ear. “Cute boy threesome,” she whispered. Kay grinned, slowly turning her shoulder.
I ignored their exchange. “Now look, I want you to keep this in mind. Michael doesn’t have a lot of experience outside of the usual boyfriend/girlfriend stuff. He’s a walking, talking orchard of cherries to be plucked. So, may I suggest some guidelines?”
“I like guidelines,” Halo smiled.
“Let’s say that if Michael wants to do something—like a threesome, or whatever—with any women, he needs to give up some cherries to earn it.”
“That sounds fun,” Kay nodded.
“Right?” I smiled. “Maybe he could be spanked, or tied up, or kiss a boy, or … sky’s the limit, really. I’m sure he would do anything at all to have a threesome with the two of you.”
“Wow, I’m going to enjoy this,” Halo said. “It will be nice to add some cherries to my collection.”
“Hmm, how many cherries do I have left?” Kay wondered. “Used to be so many …”
Michael was already at the party when we arrived. He smiled to see my familiar face, but his eyes really lit up when he saw my companions. “Hello,” he said, standing. “I’m Michael.”
“Oh, we’ve heard about you,” Halo grinned, a hint of malice in her voice.
“Yeah, we’ve got plans for you,” Kay agreed.
Michael’s smile stayed frozen to his face.
I took Smalls aside. “Let’s get a drink and watch. This should be fun.”
By the time we had poured our drinks and returned, the three of them were naked in the bedroom. Kay was blowing Michael as Halo fucked her with her hand. Michael looked over at me with bliss on his face.
“Honest to God,” I muttered to Smalls. “Some people have no imagination at all.”